Skip to Main Content

Social Networking Sites and Discovery – A Double-Edged Sword


The advent over the past decade of a plethora of social networking sites such as Facebook, MySpace and Twitter has resulted in a potential treasure-trove of discovery for employers defending lawsuits and charges filed by employees. Communications on these websites can often reveal important personal information about employees – including information that may undermine or entirely refute claims. For example, an employee's posts on a social networking site could reveal that her claims of sexual harassment are actually derived from a consensual relationship with a coworker. The information contained on these websites can also be useful in other contexts. It could reveal that an employee has a substance abuse problem, that the employee is defaming the employer or divulging trade secrets, or even that a potential employee has a history of violent behavior.

Given this potential source of invaluable information, employers often rush to access the social networking accounts of current and potential employees, even seeking to review portions of those accounts that the individuals have designated as private. A recent federal court decision from California, Crispin v. Christian Audiger, Inc., gives employers a reason for pause. Stated simply, the Crispin Court held that the portions of an employee's social networking sites designated as private are secure information under the federal Stored Communications Act (the SCA). Thus, employers may run afoul of federal law by obtaining access without permission to information on their employees' social networking sites to which the employees have selected to limit access – regardless of the number of individuals to whom they have provided access. The Crispin decision also calls into question whether an employer can obtain information from the private social networking accounts of employees even through the use of legal process such as a subpoena.

The Crispin decision may not be the last word on social networking discovery, however. In another recent federal court decision, Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Simply Storage Management LLC, the court held that the "locked" and "private" portions of the social networking accounts of two individuals claiming to have suffered severe emotional distress due to alleged sexual harassment were relevant to their claims. The court found that posts, profiles, photographs, and videos relating to the plaintiffs' mental states were discoverable, and ordered that they be disclosed.

In light of these decisions, Employers have several options to obtain and maintain access to the social networking accounts of their employees. Employers may access employees' public postings on social networking sites. If an employee's privacy settings allow the general public access to the employee's social networking information, the SCA does not restrict access. In addition, the SCA does not apply where the employee consents to disclosure. So, private employers may consider adopting a non-disparagement policy requiring employees to authorize access to their social networking sites. It remains uncertain, however, whether this requirement would constitute valid, as opposed to coerced, consent. Finally, in litigation, an employer can request the plaintiff's written consent or through discovery documents relating to plaintiff's relevant social networking site posts. If the plaintiff refuses, courts may order the plaintiff to provide consent.

For electronic discovery guidance and litigation assistance, do not hesitate to contact your Baker Donelson attorney or any of our nearly 70 Labor & Employment attorneys, located in Birmingham, Alabama; Atlanta, Georgia; Baton Rouge, Mandeville and New Orleans, Louisiana; Jackson, Mississippi; and Chattanooga, Johnson City, Knoxville, Memphis and Nashville, Tennessee.

Baker Donelson gives you what boutique labor and employment firms can't: a set of attorneys who are not only dedicated to the practice of labor and employment issues, but who can reach into an integrated and experienced team of professionals to assist you in every other aspect of your legal business needs. We set ourselves apart by valuing your entire company. And when it comes to your company's most valuable asset – your employees – we're committed to counseling with and advocating for you every step of the way.

Email Disclaimer

NOTICE: The mailing of this email is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. Anything that you send to anyone at our Firm will not be confidential or privileged unless we have agreed to represent you. If you send this email, you confirm that you have read and understand this notice.
Cancel Accept